On July 24, 1991, the Yankees crushed the Mariners 10-2, but it was a bizarre fourth-inning moment that stole the show. With two on and no outs, Pat Kelly hit a comebacker that should’ve been an easy out — but two Mariners errors turned it into a three-run fielder’s choice. The ball traveled just 59 feet, but everyone scored. Even in a blowout, that one play left fans and players shaking their heads.