On August 2, 1985, the Yankees’ rally against the White Sox unraveled in bizarre fashion. With Bobby Meacham on second and Dale Berra on first, Ricky Henderson’s drive over center looked like trouble—until Meacham stumbled after a delayed takeoff from second base. Berra was right on his heels, and both reached home plate nearly together. Carlton Fisk held firm, taking the throw, enduring a collision with Meacham, and tagging both runners out in one stunning sequence. What should have been a big inning ended in one of baseball’s rarest double plays.