Logo
Baseball Replay
LOG IN
SIGN UP
HOME
TEAMS
DECADES
ABOUT

Epic Performances

Unbelievable feats, historic games, and unforgettable moments

All Posts

Tom Browning Came Within Three Outs of Baseball Immortality

Reds

+1

/

Apr 11, 2026

Tom Browning Came Within Three Outs of Baseball Immortality

One swing denied a chance no pitcher has ever achieved

Fourteen Innings of Tension Then One Inning of Madness

Athletics

+3

/

Apr 5, 2026

Fourteen Innings of Tension Then One Inning of Madness

A marathon game ended in record-breaking fashion

When Cy Young Made One Run Feel Like Plenty

Epic Performances

+2

/

Mar 31, 2026

When Cy Young Made One Run Feel Like Plenty

The hurler known as Cyclone turned every start into a razor-thin victory

A 17-Inning Test of Wills

Reds

+3

/

Mar 26, 2026

A 17-Inning Test of Wills

Dean and Freitas endure one of baseball’s longest pitching duels

Red Sox Deliver One of Baseball’s Wildest Innings

Marlins

+3

/

Mar 15, 2026

Red Sox Deliver One of Baseball’s Wildest Innings

Boston bats around relentlessly in a 50-minute first that buries the Marlins early

A Night When Rick Wise Did Absolutely Everything

Reds

+3

/

Mar 9, 2026

A Night When Rick Wise Did Absolutely Everything

The 25-year-old Phillies pitcher threw a no-hitter—and powered the offense

Randy Jones Matches Mathewson With Masterful Control

Epic Performances

+3

/

Mar 3, 2026

Randy Jones Matches Mathewson With Masterful Control

Padres ace ties 63-year-old National League record

One Pirate’s Perfect Storm of Hits

Epic Performances

+3

/

Mar 1, 2026

One Pirate’s Perfect Storm of Hits

A record-setting performance in a 22-0 Pirates rout

He Lit Up the Night With 16 Strikeouts

Epic Performances

+3

/

Feb 27, 2026

He Lit Up the Night With 16 Strikeouts

Half a century after the last Dodger did it, Koufax made history

Curt Flood’s Sprint Stunned Houston in the 11th

1960s

+3

/

Feb 15, 2026

Curt Flood’s Sprint Stunned Houston in the 11th

A shoestring grab became a shocking game-ending dash

He Started Both Games and Finished Them Too

Reds

+3

/

Feb 12, 2026

He Started Both Games and Finished Them Too

Jack Scott’s 18-inning grind still stands alone

Don Drysdale Breaks Baseball’s Most Untouchable Pitching Record

1960s

+3

/

Feb 7, 2026

Don Drysdale Breaks Baseball’s Most Untouchable Pitching Record

A June night in 1968 finally cracked perfection—but only after history fell

Ron Guidry’s 18-Strikeout Statement

Epic Performances

+3

/

Feb 1, 2026

Ron Guidry’s 18-Strikeout Statement

The Yankees’ ace held the line on what would become an epic pennant race

The Day Fenway Belonged to Jim Pagliaroni

1960s

+3

/

Jan 30, 2026

The Day Fenway Belonged to Jim Pagliaroni

One catcher, 22 innings, and a doubleheader nobody forgot

One Start for the Ages

Epic Performances

+3

/

Jan 24, 2026

One Start for the Ages

Roger Clemens reached two unreachable numbers in one game

Nolan Ryan’s Sixth No-Hitter Came at 43

Athletics

+3

/

Jan 14, 2026

Nolan Ryan’s Sixth No-Hitter Came at 43

The ageless ace made history again, this time in Texas.

Tom Seaver’s Strikeout Avalanche

Epic Performances

+3

/

Jan 9, 2026

Tom Seaver’s Strikeout Avalanche

Ten straight punchouts punctuate an unforgettable August night

When 15 Strikeouts Still Weren’t Enough

1960s

+3

/

Jan 5, 2026

When 15 Strikeouts Still Weren’t Enough

Gary Nolan’s masterpiece ended in the cruelest possible way

Grand slams on consecutive pitches

1960s

+2

/

Jan 2, 2026

Grand slams on consecutive pitches

Jim Northrup's June 1968 explosion

Billy Williams’ Perfect Day at the Plate

Epic Performances

+3

/

Dec 31, 2025

Billy Williams’ Perfect Day at the Plate

The Cubs star turned a doubleheader into a personal hitting clinic

When a Teenager Named Koufax Announced Himself

Reds

+3

/

Dec 23, 2025

When a Teenager Named Koufax Announced Himself

A bonus baby’s second start hinted at baseball immortality

An 11th-Inning Ending For the Ages

Epic Performances

+3

/

Dec 22, 2025

An 11th-Inning Ending For the Ages

The Mets finished it out with one breathtaking final play

Rockies Rookie Rules the Day

Marlins

+3

/

Dec 11, 2025

Rockies Rookie Rules the Day

A complete-game gem—and a surprise at the plate—redefined his rocky debut year.

Maddux’s Remarkable No-Walk Run Meets an Unexpected End

Epic Performances

+3

/

Dec 8, 2025

Maddux’s Remarkable No-Walk Run Meets an Unexpected End

A record streak, two intentional passes, and a night that didn’t go Atlanta’s way

Houk’s Gamble Turns into Mantle Magic

1960s

+3

/

Dec 3, 2025

Houk’s Gamble Turns into Mantle Magic

A hobbled Mick delivers a storybook swing when the Yankees need it most

Load more

Baseball Replay

Relive the moments that shaped your love for the game, through the eyes of the journalists who covered them

I consent to receive newsletters via email. Sign up Terms of service.